Skip to main content

Film review · 2002

Ice Age

***

Reviewed by: Angus Wolfe Murray

Ice Age
"In the end, you care more about the acorn than the baby."

Surprisingly, this has nothing to do with the ice age. It's snowy and cold, but that doesn't mean whole continents are going to change and species become extinct. It could be winter in Canada, except the animals are wrong.

It's the story of three unlikely companions going on a journey with a baby. The companions are a sloth, a mammoth and a sabre-toothed tiger. The baby's mother drowns in a river and the wild creatures decide to take the toddler to its daddy.

Copy pictureAs a synopsis, this should not have passed first base. The mammoth would have killed the tiger. The tiger would have killed the sloth. All of them would have killed the baby. But this is the wonderful world of animation and you can cry if you want to.

Sid the sloth is a weedy apologetic type, wisecracking his way out of being scared to death. Manny the mammoth is a bit of a softy, as well as wise, etc. Diego the tiger has an image prob. He knows he's the prince of the jungle, being a big cat - except this jungle is frozen - and should be murdering everything in sight, including people, especially little people, like babies, but can't, because (sigh) he kinda loves 'em.

The script isn't witty enough. Imagine, if you dare, the whole of The Lion King being the middle bit, with those goofy animals. That's what this is. Just add snow. The adventure doesn't contain half the excitement of Balto, or quarter the fun of Toy Story 2. It could be compared to Monsters Inc, because that was a story of misfit buddies taking care of a human child. The baby in Ice doesn't have a character. It's cute in a goo-goo, no poo, cuddlesome-wuddlesome way. The little girl in Monsters had genuine personality that made the whole difference, adding greatly to the success of the movie.

There is a running gag that gives an indication of what this might have been. It comes in the form of an odd-looking rat that is trying to bury an acorn. It's not a squirrel, although does squirrelish things, and the joke is that it can't find anywhere to put the stupid nut, because the ground's too hard and volcanoes tend to erupt around it and mountains of ice collapse. In cartoon terms, it's funnier than anything, but isn't included in the body of the plot. It's like a stand-up comedian who fills in when they're changing the furniture back stage.

In the end, you care more about the acorn than the baby.

Reviewed on: 24 Mar 2002

Source JustWatch

If you like this, try:

Eight Below
Review preview for Eight Below

Kids will find it long and slow, with only one truly scary moment, and dads won't believe a word of it.

Angus Wolfe Murray · 3 out of 5
Ice Age 2: The Meltdown
Review preview for Ice Age 2: The Meltdown

I've seen cooked spaghetti with more tension.

Amber Wilkinson · 3 out of 5
Madagascar
Review preview for Madagascar

Formulaically funny and kids will adore every derivative minute.

Kotleta · 4 out of 5