Skip to main content

Reviews by Andrew Robertson

Order by: Date, A–Z

  • In The Meadow (2010)
    Review preview for In The Meadow

    From a gentle start In The Meadow gets very dark, very quickly.

    Andrew Robertson · 4 out of 5
    A middle-aged man and his young mistress head for a birthday picnic in the countryside. At least, that's the plan.
  • The Cull (2010)
    Review preview for The Cull

    Andrew Walker's script is short on words but has plenty of depth, and Jonathan Harris' direction is assured.

    Andrew Robertson · 3 out of 5
    A boy clashes with his father as the older man tries to teach him about life on a remote Peak District farm.
  • Alice (2010)
    Review preview for Alice

    A beautifully shot little film.

    Andrew Robertson · 4 out of 5
    A young girl has a magical experience when taken to a theatrical performance of Alice In Wonderland.
  • The Lucky Ones (2009)
    Review preview for The Lucky Ones

    In just under half an hour we get a glimpse into scores of lives, all just after major changes.

    Andrew Robertson · 4 out of 5
    The comings and goings at a Registry Office in Krakow.
  • The Veil (2009)
    Review preview for The Veil

    A touching portrait of women with a calling.

    Andrew Robertson · 3 out of 5
    The secret life of a nunnery in Venice.
  • Launderette (2010)
    Review preview for Launderette

    A lovely little portrait of a nocturnal community.

    Andrew Robertson · 3 out of 5
    A look at the lives of those visiting a launderette.
  • Gypsy Cab (2009)
    Review preview for Gypsy Cab

    With sandy docklands, rusting hulks, the taxi we follow drifts through an unfathomable landscape.

    Andrew Robertson · 3.5 out of 5
    The phenomenon of the 'gypsy cab' - Russian, spontaneous, unlicensed taxis.
  • The Mystery Of Flying Kicks (2010)
    Review preview for The Mystery Of Flying Kicks

    At times this appears to be a documentary about looking things up on Google.

    Andrew Robertson · 3 out of 5
    Documenting the phenomenon of trainers being left hanging from telephone poles, trees and the like.
  • Barber's Dozen (2009)
    Review preview for Barber's Dozen

    Entertaining, amusing, like a humorous conversation overheard on the train.

    Andrew Robertson · 3 out of 5
    The tales of people who frequent a barber's shop chair.
  • Strawberry Girl (2009)
    Review preview for Strawberry Girl

    A fascinating little film.

    Andrew Robertson · 3.5 out of 5
    A girl talks about her hellish summer job on a strawberry farm.
  • My Son, My Son, What Have Ye Done? (2009)
    Review preview for My Son, My Son, What Have Ye Done?

    This is brilliant.

    Andrew Robertson · 5 out of 5
    Two detectives try to work out how a young man came to kill his mother with a sword.
  • R: Hit First, Hit Hardest (2010)
    Review preview for R: Hit First, Hit Hardest

    A triumph of naturalistic storytelling, of symbolism, aided by tremendous technical work.

    Andrew Robertson · 4.5 out of 5
    Sentenced for an unexplained stabbing, a young man enters a violent prison.
  • Two In The Wave (2009)
    Review preview for Two In The Wave

    Two In The Wave is informative without ever feeling didactic, entertaining in and of itself, and aided by a subject that's likely to be of interest to filmgoers anyway.

    Andrew Robertson · 4 out of 5
    Account of the friendship between Truffaut and Godard.
  • Save Our Bacon (2010)
    Review preview for Save Our Bacon

    A tasty treat.

    Andrew Robertson · 4 out of 5
    A farmer needs ten more pigs in a hurry, but the only one he has turns her snout up at prospective suitors.
  • A Family Portrait (2009)
    Review preview for A Family Portrait

    Ingenious, convincing, and powerful.

    Andrew Robertson · 3.5 out of 5
    A family portrait session reveals underlying jealousies.
  • The Silence Of Sons (2010)
    Review preview for The Silence Of Sons

    Visually this is one of the best short films at the Edinburgh Film Festival, so distinctive in its appearance that it will leave you wanting more.

    Andrew Robertson · 5 out of 5
    A hoarder manages to obtain a precious cupboard in impoverished Eastern Europe, but the cost may be higher than he imagined.
  • Sky-Caper (2009)
    Review preview for Sky-Caper

    Integrating the work of two animators can't have been easy, but the pair are clearly capable of handling the technical challenges.

    Andrew Robertson · 3 out of 5
    A window-washing duel.
  • Atomic Hubbub (2009)
    Review preview for Atomic Hubbub

    For its brevity, it still manages to raise a fair few laughs.

    Andrew Robertson · 3 out of 5
    Helpful advice on what to do to survive a nuclear attack.
  • Shadow Play (2010)
    Review preview for Shadow Play

    Funny stuff.

    Andrew Robertson · 4 out of 5
    A group of shadow characters embark on a strange adventure.
  • Out Of The Ashes (2010)
    Review preview for Out Of The Ashes

    A film with moments of striking beauty, compassion, and more than a few sporting thrills.

    Andrew Robertson · 4 out of 5
    The story of the unexpected rise and rise of the Afghan cricket team.
  • Ollie Kepler's Expanding Purple World (2010)
    Review preview for Ollie Kepler's Expanding Purple World

    That it comes so close to being fair, to being true, is to its credit.

    Andrew Robertson · 2.5 out of 5
    A man with a passion for astrophysics experiences a schizophrenic break after suffering a bereavement.
  • Battenberg (2010)
    Review preview for Battenberg

    Unsettling, concerning, rewarding.

    Andrew Robertson · 4.5 out of 5
    Colliding with the dusty window of an abandoned guest-house, an unwitting bird fails to realise the curious horror lurking within.
  • Welcome To Twister (2009)
    Review preview for Welcome To Twister

    Welcome To Twister is ultimately hampered by its visuals.

    Andrew Robertson · 2 out of 5
    An old man makes up a bed-time story for his three grandchildren... but things get wild in the Old West when they start to join in.
  • Spin (2010)
    Review preview for Spin

    It's dark in places, intentionally so, and that's also to the credit of those involved.

    Andrew Robertson · 3.5 out of 5
    Synchronised soldiering meets Busby Berkeley
  • The Rhythm Of The Story: The Quest (2009)
    Review preview for The Rhythm Of The Story: The Quest

    From the notes it apparently abstracts different theoretical elements from a variety of disciplines, but in practise it's a field of flashing shapes with something approaching music in the background.

    Andrew Robertson · 1 out of 5
    Abstract film about story.
  • What Light (Through Yonder Window Breaks) (2009)
    Review preview for What Light (Through Yonder Window Breaks)

    This is amazing: ephemeral, illuminating, ingenious.

    Andrew Robertson · 5 out of 5
    Sunlight cast through a window breaks free and takes on a life of its own.
  • Bruce (2009)
    Review preview for Bruce

    Entertaining, inventive, and bleak.

    Andrew Robertson · 5 out of 5
    Using synthetic biological technology, a young man grows his own action hero.
  • Savage Mountain (2009)
    Review preview for Savage Mountain

    Given how ably it delivers it would be churlish to ask for more.

    Andrew Robertson · 4 out of 5
    As food runs low and tensions run high on the slopes of Savage Mountain, something sinister is at hand.
  • Fly On The Window (2009)
    Review preview for Fly On The Window

    Though it's light on plot it's more about how things are seen rather than what.

    Andrew Robertson · 3 out of 5
    A moody animation from the perspective of a fly observing someone's home.
  • The Red Machine (2009)
    Review preview for The Red Machine

    Every actor has a chance to shine, and none fails to take it.

    Andrew Robertson · 4.5 out of 5
    A young thief is persuaded to help a US government agency steal a Japanese encryption device on the eve of war.
  • One Thousand Pictures: RFK's Last Journey (2009)
    Review preview for One Thousand Pictures: RFK's Last Journey

    Tremendous.

    Andrew Robertson · 4.5 out of 5
    Documentary on the journey of Robert Kennedy's funeral train.
  • Arnica (2010)
    Review preview for Arnica

    Compelling, intriguing, and brief.

    Andrew Robertson · 3.5 out of 5
    A young man tries to reconcile with his father through football.
  • Ashura (2010)
    Review preview for Ashura

    While this is a short film it carries within it the seeds of dread, hope, and waiting.

    Andrew Robertson · 3 out of 5
    Film borne out of artist's residency with Edinburgh Mela.
  • Melissa Immaculate (2009)
    Review preview for Melissa Immaculate

    A heartwarming little portrait.

    Andrew Robertson · 3 out of 5
    Melissa is about to become a Roman Catholic and cameras track her preperations.
  • Crook And The Highlandman (2010)
    Review preview for Crook And The Highlandman

    Short, lyric, a minor epic.

    Andrew Robertson · 4 out of 5
    Factual film about the life of one of the members of mental health programme Stepping Stones.
  • Skip 11 (2009)
    Review preview for Skip 11

    Kevin is personable, talented, able, and Christopher Lewis Cook's film captures his time in Stockbridge brilliantly.

    Andrew Robertson · 4 out of 5
    Observing the construction of an artwork in Stockbridge, Edinburgh.
  • María's Way (2009)
    Review preview for María's Way

    A gentle, touching, a portrait of a woman with a calling.

    Andrew Robertson · 3 out of 5
    Story of a woman who greets those on the pilgrimage route to Santiago de Compostela in Spain
  • Just Before Dawn (2010)
    Review preview for Just Before Dawn

    There's certainly potential, and talent, but nothing comes of it.

    Andrew Robertson · 2.5 out of 5
    Two women try to rediscover their youth an an isolated countryside party.
  • Dust (2010)
    Review preview for Dust

    This is an alternate reality, let us say, but a convincing one.

    Andrew Robertson · 4.5 out of 5
    The unexpected predicament of Apollo 18 astronaut Glen Gordon.
  • Until The River Runs Red (2010)
    Review preview for Until The River Runs Red

    It's powerful, stunning, the whole film is haunting.

    Andrew Robertson · 5 out of 5
    A mysterious girl claims to be the second coming of Jesus, but why are the police investigating her disappearance?
  • Electric Light Wonderland (2009)
    Review preview for Electric Light Wonderland

    Shot in ultra-closeup on occasion, confined, claustrophobic.

    Andrew Robertson · 3.5 out of 5
    Three men unpack a mobile discotheque, quietly musing on what is to come.
  • Turning (2010)
    Review preview for Turning

    The opening is strong, the end fair, there is mystery and wonderment - it becomes hard to single out anything because it's all good; brilliant, even.

    Andrew Robertson · 5 out of 5
    An unlikely tea party takes place to celebrate a birthday.
  • I'll Be Right Here (2010)
    Review preview for I'll Be Right Here

    The risk for a film that focuses on film is that it'll reference something that does what it's trying to do better.

    Andrew Robertson · 2 out of 5
    A deranged and delusional screenwriter Moffat is holed up in an LA hotel room, ready to meet his idol Steven Spielberg.
  • Defoe (2009)
    Review preview for Defoe

    Visually it's a delight, but spectacle is not enough.

    Andrew Robertson · 2.5 out of 5
    Sci-fi short about a shipwrecked traveller, a strange desolate land and a fateful clash with the locals.
  • An Act of Love (2010)
    Review preview for An Act of Love

    There's time to wonder if this might have played better as a sketch in some other show.

    Andrew Robertson · 2 out of 5
    A man agrees to help his partner's sister have a baby.
  • The Illusionist (2010)
    Review preview for The Illusionist

    The Illusionist has a sense of humour, a sense of wonder, and a sense of place, and in combination that's enough to make it magical.

    Andrew Robertson · 4 out of 5
    A stage entertainer dedicated to a dying art finds his life transformed by a chance encounter with a young devotee.
  • Wake In Fright (1971)
    Review preview for Wake In Fright

    This is a shocking, visceral work. There are moments of humour, here and there, but it is the gallows laughing.

    Andrew Robertson · 4.5 out of 5
    A young teacher gets more than he bargained for in a violent outback town, in a film that reportedly even gives Nick Cave nightmares...
  • Ondine (2009)
    Review preview for Ondine

    Annie is played by newcomer Alison Barry, and she's amazing.

    Andrew Robertson · 4.5 out of 5
    A fisherman drags up a woman in his net, but she's not dead - is she a supernatural creature?
  • Law Abiding Citizen (2009)
    Review preview for Law Abiding Citizen

    Flails about through a series of ostensible set-pieces until it reaches a conclusion that verges on the nonsensical.

    Andrew Robertson · 1.5 out of 5
    A man whose family has been murdered seeks revenge on the killers - and on the legal personnel who enabled them to escape justice.
  • Dead Man Running (2009)
    Review preview for Dead Man Running

    It's somewhat pedestrian, predicated on decisions that appear ludicrous, and its smartest observation might well be an accident.

    Andrew Robertson · 2 out of 5
    An ex-con goes on a desperate hunt for money to pay back a loan shark who is holding his mother hostage.

News and features

Paul Rowley on moving to New York, the Pulse massacre, and Gays Against Guns

'It was written for him' Declan Recks on comedy drama One Sweet Hour and its late star Gary Lydon

All at sea Max Fisher on refugee journeys, anti-migrant sentiment and Rule, Britannia

Fishing for identity Pete Muller on questions of masculinity and how it passes down the generations in Bucks Harbor

A step ahead of the others Leading Italian filmmakers on the legacy of Robert Rossellini

True to her nature Hanna Bergholm on storytelling, emotional truth and Nightborn

Painting history Pauline Julier and Nicolas Chapoulier on imagining the journey of a 17th century portait in Les Indes

Fatherland leads European Film Awards nominations La Bola Negra hot on its heels

More news and features

Festival coverage

Festivals
Cannes festival coverage, 2026

We're bringing you all the latest news and reviews from the Cheltenham International Film Festival, the Leeds International Film Festival, the Thessaloniki International Film Festival and Tallinn Black Nights.



We're looking forward to the French Film Festival and DOC NYC.



We've recently brought you coverage of the Belfast Film Festival, Halloween Frightfest, the Scottish Queer International Film Festival, Newfest, the London Film Festival, the New York Film Festival and Grimmfest.



Read our full for more.


Visit our festivals section.